What makes you respond to my question with a question? Can't you just answer if you do or you do not?Originally Posted by straightXed
What makes you respond to my question with a question? Can't you just answer if you do or you do not?Originally Posted by straightXed
What makes you respond to his question with a question? Can't you just answer why you thought he didnt practice any martial arts?Originally Posted by xCrucialDudex
That was me who asked him a question first. That's why.Originally Posted by rodrigo
Because it was as if you thought the values i mentioned were conclusive enough to suggest i didn't practice a particular martial art even though the values are clearly found in many martial arts. So i asked why, based on me mentioning values found in martial arts, you deduced that i did not practice martial arts? The answer to my question isn't immediately apparent where as the answer to what you are asking is answered in abundance within this thread.Originally Posted by xCrucialDudex
Perhaps the answers already present don't satisfy you in which case i suggest if you want a different answer you ask a different question. I mean come on, you are asking if i practice martial arts and my first thread says "i am a martial artist", also i later go on to mention my sifu as well as discussing martial arts and the qualities found within them - and from all that you arrive at an idea that i don't do martial arts?
Now tell me, after taking all of the afore mentioned facts into consideration, do i really need to answer the question?
Others walk the bow, I walk the string
I was just curious if he does any martial arts or not. So I decided to ask him a question expecting him to *actually* give me back a "yes/no" (at least) kind of answer. But I got back a question instead.Originally Posted by rodrigo
A question that had already been answered within this thread yet i still don't think my question has been answered, i mean its like you are in the twilight zone or something, i say i'm a martial artist and you derrive from that an idea that i don't do martial arts, its pretty odd.Originally Posted by xCrucialDudex
Others walk the bow, I walk the string
Dude, i said i was a martial artist, what do you think martial artists do?Originally Posted by xCrucialDudex
Others walk the bow, I walk the string
I didn't really mean to say that you don't do MA. On the contrary I just wanted to specify what martial arts exactly you study.Originally Posted by straightXed
And that's the issue. Since the values you described are found in a number of MA I got curious about what specific MA you do.Originally Posted by straightXed
Not really.Originally Posted by straightXed
So what MA exactly do you do?Originally Posted by straightXed
I am not asking if you just do some MA arts or you don't. I'm asking what MA exactly do you do?Originally Posted by straightXed
I'm afraid you need to.Originally Posted by straightXed
I didn't derive an idea that "you don't do martial arts". Again, on the contrary I understood that you have some knowledge on the subject discussed and I deduced that apparently you must be doing some MA. What MA exactly you do was all I wanted to get from you at that point.Originally Posted by straightXed
I guess me being in "twilight zone or something" like putting a question in a wrong way is what created so much misunderstanding.
Well say what you mean then!Originally Posted by xCrucialDudex
Well seeing as values are similar throughout, the particular style becomes rather unimportant. Lets think of the style of no style and not get caught up in rather unimportant factors within martial arts. I mean i was more specific on my martial philosophy than i could ever be in naming a style.Originally Posted by xCrucialDudex
Yes really, remember you were the one who jumped to a conclusion that i didn't do a martial art at all after i clearly spoke of martial elements after saying i was a martial artist. You began asking a question that really didn't need asking and now you are even agreeing that what you were curious about is which art i did yet you suggested i didn't do any art? Which is why it was your question that was flawed which is why i questioned it, so you could either rephrase it, rethink it or whatever.Originally Posted by xCrucialDudex
you can call it the art of fighting without fighting!Originally Posted by xCrucialDudex
Thats what you are asking now but not what you were asking before, and it still doesn't answer why you came to the conclusion that i didn't do any martial arts does it?Originally Posted by xCrucialDudex
No, you have asked a different question than the one you asked before. Before you asked:Originally Posted by xCrucialDudex
"I see. So you do not practice any particular MA such as Taek-won-do/Karate/Aikido/Boxing/etc., do you?"
now a martial artist would be someone that practices a particular martial art would they not?
you also asked:
Can't you just answer if you do or you do not?
which is also answered by my saying i am a martial artist. So i am afraid to answer the questions you have asked up until this post i am quoting i should not need to answer as the answers are already available. You have now asked a different question, which i answered with a semi joke (its more truth than joke to be honest).
It was indeed up to you to revise your question which is why i questioned it as what you were asking didn't need answering. So it wasn't me who needed to answer the question it was you who needed to ask the question first, now you have finally decided to ask what you wanted an answer to i will answer you. Although the information has been present in my profile the whole time, i train and teach yip family wing chun...but you can call it the art of fighting without fighting.
Others walk the bow, I walk the string
Well you derived this "So you do not practice any particular MA such as Taek-won-do/Karate/Aikido/Boxing/etc., do you?" which pretty much suggests you were of the opinion and needed clarity that i didn't do any particular martial arts.Originally Posted by xCrucialDudex
If you wanted to know what martial art idid the best thing you can do is ask that, not ask questions that assume i don't to martial arts, because before i answer i will want to clarify why you think i don't after i said i do. Like i said, it was the question that was wrong.
again, the question wasn't the wrong way it was just plain the wrong question in contrast with what you actually wanted to ask.Originally Posted by xCrucialDudex
Others walk the bow, I walk the string
For anyone who doesn't know about yip family wing chun or wing chun in general here is a laymans guide complete with brummy accents focusing on an ex cheif instructor of mine, sifu shaun rawcliffe.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9ANxwDnBxsY
And for those who found that a bit yawn worthy heres a cheesy music video from a new york sifu focusing on wing chun. Sifu jose grados:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9vUCCtb9uOs
Last edited by straightXed; 07-25-2007 at 05:06 PM.
Others walk the bow, I walk the string
i wanted to practice wing chun with my girlfriend, but at the moment i couldnt afford them... and, i still cant, but when i get a second job im gonna go there and join up!
I will!Originally Posted by straightXed
Jeez, can't you just answer directly the question I asked, can you?Originally Posted by straightXed
Why did you decide that I'm interested now in all these details?
All I wanted (and still want to) was the name of the martial arts you practice. No more no less.
I'm open to new information and that's something you actually give when you go into detailed explanations. That's fine but I just want to know the name of MA you practice.
Are you trying to avoid answering my question directly?
Okay, let me remind you that the English language isn't my first language so chances are that I failed to express my thoughts the right way. I'll repeat it again - I understood that you were into MA and doing a particular one. I was just trying to specify the name of MA you practice.Originally Posted by straightXed
See above and all of my prior posts trying to reach you with my message "I didn't even try to suggest that you don't do MA".Originally Posted by straightXed
Originally Posted by straightXed
Yes, I could really rephrase it, rethink it or whatever. The next time I'll do before posting.
There's no such MA, is there? I never heard of it before and moreover it doesn't really sound as the name of MA. I'll try it again - I want to know the name of MA you practice.Originally Posted by straightXed
Please, see above.Originally Posted by straightXed
I think that a martial artist is someone that practices a particular MA (such as Aikido, Karate, Jiu-Jitsu, etc.)Originally Posted by straightXed
I figured that you are early on. That's not the point of my question.Originally Posted by straightXed
Then you should consider answering the new ones. In fact, if you answer the only one it'll be just great: What's the name of MA that you practice?Originally Posted by straightXed
I can't see the answer to my question (coming before this quoting) in your responds. Do you expect me to guess it myself?Originally Posted by straightXed
I agree that I should've rephrased my question. My fault.Originally Posted by straightXed
I asked it, but I asked it the wrong way. Which is a quite a different story.Originally Posted by straightXed
Thank you so much. That's all I wanted to know.Originally Posted by straightXed
Now if you don't mind my asking, please, tell me what makes you write so many commentaries to posts of others? Honestly, I'm curious about it.
Last edited by xCrucialDudex; 07-26-2007 at 01:18 AM.
Thanks for explanations. It'll help me to avoid asking wrong questions next time.Originally Posted by straightXed
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Bookmarks