Search:

I'm not actually telling you what you aren't i'm talking about how straightedge doesn't work as a label for everything you are.





I feel something different to you, i could be saying right...

This is not what i said at all, it can lead anywhere but where it leads, be it spiritual or physical, doesn't become an element of straightedge.




Thats fine and for many people straightedge...

If it cannot be defined and is allowed to mean something different to everyone then it really has no meaning at all. Its not about being militant or judgemental its simply just that if you use a...

Why does it have to be one person? It wasn't one person it was and is a bunch of people and it is continually defined through their actions and their words.





How is it not definitive of...

I answered the question, if you would like me to go further into what sound, content and ethic then perhaps you should inspire me to want to discuss things with you. Heres what i suggest, go and...

You don't really endear people to the idea of helping you.

You are a guru.

its sound, content and ethic.

Are they a straightedge band then?

I never said it was, there you go again reading things that weren't written.



Well no, thats not obvious at all, just because a band says calls themselves something doesn't make it so. However...

See you don't even know what hardcore is! If you aren't supporting straightedge hardcore you aren't supporting straightedge.Being in a mosh pit doesn't matter but you didn't even know what sing...

Perhaps you should spend more time reading the threads here before quickly reacting. I personally don't consider terror a hardcore band.



thats nice.



ummm, no and underground scene can...

Is hardly fascist to use accurate definitions, i'm not fascist about people being drug free but why would they need the term straightedge when that boils down to hardcore + being drug free. ...

Why can't they benifit from being drug free and leave straightedge in tack. I mean theres nothing wrong with taking influence from straightedge but stripping it down and still calling it the same...

I don't think its that misleading, if you follow the whole argument.

Sxe is hardcore as in not removable from hardcore, hardcore is not straightedge as in not solely made up of sxe and doesn't need to be straightedge at all. Pretty simple. Use the quote button dude,...

Yeah, who said there would be no hardcore without straightedge?

Yeah surely thats not straightedge once its evolved, its starting point may have began at straightedge but you finding yourself thinking about and questioning other aspects of your life doesn't get...