minor threat
refused
kid dynamite
casey jones
reaching forward
ten yard fight
warzone
champion
youth of today
25 ta life
judge
gorilla biscuits
vitamin x
good clean fun
bold
slapshot
7seconds :for the most importants i know
Printable View
minor threat
refused
kid dynamite
casey jones
reaching forward
ten yard fight
warzone
champion
youth of today
25 ta life
judge
gorilla biscuits
vitamin x
good clean fun
bold
slapshot
7seconds :for the most importants i know
i forgot earth crisis
kid dynamite wassn't. warzone wasn't. 25 ta life arent.Quote:
Originally Posted by xRodboi!x
i thought 25 ta life were coz i thought rick was sxe.25 ta life can be considered as a one man band.I forgot Battery and Better than a thousandQuote:
Originally Posted by xsecx
he is, but the rest ofthe band isn't.Quote:
Originally Posted by xRodboi!x
i always thought he was a druggieQuote:
Originally Posted by xsecx
donīt you like them?Quote:
Originally Posted by xsecx
no, but regardless, they're not an edge band.Quote:
Originally Posted by straight sam
hmm... but they say so ? I donīt know, donīt wanna say somethinQuote:
Originally Posted by xsecx
do they?Quote:
Originally Posted by straight sam
I heard so...
eighteen visions is
they've said it in interviews
and xRAINx
Definitely not what i would call hardcore.Quote:
Originally Posted by kaytee187x
Minor Threat
Youth Of Today
(early)glassJAw
xbustedx
Sons Of Abraham
Slapeshot
Throwdown
busted?Quote:
Originally Posted by xbustedx
yeah it was a small sxe band out of Long Island NY.Quote:
Originally Posted by SgtD
that name isn't too good pickQuote:
Originally Posted by xbustedx
Quote:
Originally Posted by SgtD
can you please make sure your grammar was correct please. Because I didn't understand what you said.
Its not a good name to pick would be what i thought he was getting at.Quote:
Originally Posted by xbustedx
what Ed saidQuote:
Originally Posted by xbustedx
I'm pretty sure glassjaw was never a straight edge band. throwdown is also currently questionable. historically yes, but now it's not quite as clear.Quote:
Originally Posted by xbustedx
Quote:
Originally Posted by xsecx
As far as I know, Throwdown are still an edge band, even with the new members they are all edge. They were talking about it in the DVD that came with Vendetta, so unless things have changed since that release i think they are still edge.
there's no mention of it anywhere in the band bio. band website went from xthrowdownx.com to throwdowngo.com, etc.Quote:
Originally Posted by mouseman004
glassJAw was a sxe when it first started.Quote:
Originally Posted by xsecx
although your correct it didn't last long.
and as far as I know Throwdown Is stil sxe.
what are you basing this on?Quote:
Originally Posted by xbustedx
people in the band might be, but that doesn't mean they're still promoting or calling themselves a straight edge band. there is a difference.Quote:
Originally Posted by xbustedx
i would definately assume that throwdown is still edge because they still sell edge merchandise and they put at least one straight edge song on every album. I agree that they are promoting it less now but I would say they are still and edge band
selling stuff because it makes them money and being a band with edge people in it , vs being a straight edge band are 2 different things.Quote:
Originally Posted by mouseman004
Quote:
Originally Posted by xsecx
They can sell non edge merchandise and make just as much money. my point is, they would probably not be selling shirts that say "Throwdown: Straight Edge" if they were not an edge band
then if that's the case, then why change the website and why not even include in your band bio?Quote:
Originally Posted by mouseman004
conversations I have had with Daryl Palumbo (lead singer)Quote:
Originally Posted by xsecx
even so, they never put out a straight edge record, and were never a straight edge band. they may have intended to be at the beginning but never were.Quote:
Originally Posted by xbustedx
They were playing sxe music. Long before they ever put out an album. Your right they never put out a sxe album. But they were a sxe band.Quote:
Originally Posted by xsecx
sure thing dude, but in the scheme of things and in relative terms, they weren't and shouldn't be included in discussions of straight edge bands if the extent of their time as an edge band was early on and never recorded.Quote:
Originally Posted by xbustedx
if you say so. but I don't think that we should exclude discussing sxe bands just because they were never recorded. But its your forum and yoru rules. So, understood.Quote:
Originally Posted by xsecx
if a tree falls in the forest, does it make a sound? How much impact is a band going to have in terms of edge if people don't hear the songs, aren't played and were never recorded?Quote:
Originally Posted by xbustedx
thats not true I am sure lots of people hear bands long before they record anything. And I am sure that they have impacts on their own sxe community.Quote:
Originally Posted by xsecx
hearing them and them having an impact aren't the same thing. with this case in point, when people talk about and think about glassjaw it's not to do with straight edge at all, because they had no impact on the scene or the movement in general.Quote:
Originally Posted by xbustedx
Not to interrupt, but xNeverxAgainx, Suffocate Faster, xTyrantx.
Sorry if they've already been listed, I didn't want to go through every page of this thread.