PDA

View Full Version : master list



Pages : [1] 2

xsecx
10-07-2003, 06:59 AM
now might be a good time to start forming a master list of sxe bands.
first person to say anti flag gets a nutsack.

XprennaX
10-07-2003, 09:31 AM
Minor Threat
Gorilla Biscuits
Youth of Today
Slapshot






and isn't that guy from AFI sxe?http://sxe.com/forums/images/smilies/smile.gif

xsecx
10-07-2003, 09:41 AM
Originally posted by XprennaX
Minor Threat
Gorilla Biscuits
Youth of Today
Slapshot






and isn't that guy from AFI sxe?http://sxe.com/forums/images/smilies/smile.gif

yeah davey is.

straightXed
10-07-2003, 10:41 AM
Judge
Floorpunch
Ten yard fight
bloodpact
wide awake

xsecx
10-07-2003, 11:11 AM
ssd
dys
uniform choice
judge
gorilla biscuits
atari
strife
undertow
brotherhood

linsee
10-07-2003, 11:47 AM
anti flag....
wait i already have a nutsack

xdevastorx

flame_still_burns
10-07-2003, 11:58 AM
slapshot aren't straightedge because they ate meat.

just kidding.

turning point
mouthpiece
unbroken
mean season
insted
lifetime
ressurection
earth crisis
project x
no for an answer
chain of strength
outspoken
release
bold


just out of curiosity what's the deal with anti-flag? when i was doing shows this guy pat from that band used to call me for shows all the time...but just guessing by their name i figured they weren't quite what we were into doing. i've still never heard them...they aren't trying to be a straightedge band are they?

xsecx
10-07-2003, 06:30 PM
Originally posted by flame_still_burns
slapshot aren't straightedge because they ate meat.

just kidding.

turning point
mouthpiece
unbroken
mean season
insted
lifetime
ressurection
earth crisis
project x
no for an answer
chain of strength
outspoken
release
bold


just out of curiosity what's the deal with anti-flag? when i was doing shows this guy pat from that band used to call me for shows all the time...but just guessing by their name i figured they weren't quite what we were into doing. i've still never heard them...they aren't trying to be a straightedge band are they?

pretty much your generic anti government political punk thing.

Dummy
10-07-2003, 07:55 PM
but i think they're all straightedge, just not a straightedge band
champion
stay gold
brotherhood
over my dead body
judge
and also jade from AFI is edge....or was it hunter? i think jade.

straightXed
10-08-2003, 03:00 AM
Originally posted by Dummy
but i think they're all straightedge, just not a straightedge band
champion
stay gold
brotherhood
over my dead body
judge
and also jade from AFI is edge....or was it hunter? i think jade.

Hunter....jade....arent they gladiators?

Dummy
10-09-2003, 12:00 AM
no i think they are characters in mortal kombat

linsee
10-09-2003, 12:10 AM
you guys are such nerds

Dummy
10-09-2003, 12:43 AM
so ive heard

straightXed
10-09-2003, 01:45 AM
Originally posted by linsee
you guys are such nerds

haha, says linsee the nerd

linsee
10-09-2003, 01:58 AM
Originally posted by straightXed
haha, says linsee the nerd

you are in trouble

Dummy
10-09-2003, 07:45 PM
Originally posted by linsee
you are in trouble

for 25 ta life.

straightXed
10-10-2003, 09:58 AM
time x, just had to mention them, why am i in trouble?

xstabex
10-11-2003, 11:17 AM
What about Bane?

They are/were.

Dummy
10-13-2003, 01:18 AM
i personally don't likethem.

johneric
10-13-2003, 02:18 AM
where is h20?

straightXed
10-13-2003, 09:58 AM
Originally posted by johneric
where is h20?

In the tap?

xsecx
10-16-2003, 03:15 PM
Originally posted by johneric
where is h20?

most definetly not an edge band.

carry nation.
stand and fight
commitment
battery
chorus of disapproval
blade crasher
count me out
embrace today
fastbreak
floorpunch
no reply
turning point
uniform choice

xgcfx
10-19-2003, 12:50 PM
All that I wanted to add was added....

straightfaced
10-21-2003, 11:17 AM
h2o is too an edge band... well at least all the members of the band are edge. which is pretty much the samething.

straightXed
10-21-2003, 12:21 PM
Originally posted by straightfaced
h2o is too an edge band... well at least all the members of the band are edge. which is pretty much the samething.

Was it a one man band then? I was under the impression that only toby morse was edge, apart form his fucking mind being warped. The rest of them all smoke and drink and all that shit.

xsecx
10-21-2003, 05:36 PM
Originally posted by straightfaced
h2o is too an edge band... well at least all the members of the band are edge. which is pretty much the samething.

yeah you're smoking some crack. toby is the only one. the rest are most def not.
listen to the first record where they talk some shit.

xsecx
10-21-2003, 05:37 PM
Originally posted by straightXed
Was it a one man band then? I was under the impression that only toby morse was edge, apart form his fucking mind being warped. The rest of them all smoke and drink and all that shit.

god bless the first record.

DON'T FORGET THE STRUGGLE. DON'T FORGET TO REUSE WARZONE LYRICS!

AxZxHxC
10-21-2003, 08:44 PM
charles bronson

xMAROONx

straightXed
10-22-2003, 03:17 AM
Originally posted by xsecx
god bless the first record.

DON'T FORGET THE STRUGGLE. DON'T FORGET TO REUSE WARZONE LYRICS!

Hehehe, i liked that record except the last track was soooooo bad.

flame_still_burns
10-22-2003, 07:14 AM
Originally posted by xsecx
battery


you inspired me to go dig in the archives and pull out my battery seven inch and give it a spin for old times sake...good stuff. i used to have the insert with the 'dc straightedge' jacket hanging on my wall. where did all the time go...?

ps: that record that a few guitar solos don't kill hardcore...but they're hard to pull off.

xsecx
10-22-2003, 07:54 AM
Originally posted by flame_still_burns
you inspired me to go dig in the archives and pull out my battery seven inch and give it a spin for old times sake...good stuff. i used to have the insert with the 'dc straightedge' jacket hanging on my wall. where did all the time go...?

ps: that record that a few guitar solos don't kill hardcore...but they're hard to pull off.

that record is amazing. I still want a dc straight edge letter jacket. at some point, I'll probably get one and represent the old style.

ONLY.....THE DIEHARD........REMAIN!

flame_still_burns
10-22-2003, 08:08 AM
Originally posted by xsecx
that record is amazing. I still want a dc straight edge letter jacket. at some point, I'll probably get one and represent the old style.

ONLY.....THE DIEHARD........REMAIN!

i forgot to put the 'proves' in the part about the solos, but i guess you figured it out.

straightedge letter jackets are what it's all about. i used to have one... and it was even a champion brand... but this girl who was my roommate stole it and took off the letters.

ps: do you know mike mcternan..and is if so is he still edge? last time i saw him was probably 94 or 95 ish... at the rate he was going then he is probably 100% tattooed now.

xsecx
10-22-2003, 08:14 AM
Originally posted by flame_still_burns
i forgot to put the 'proves' in the part about the solos, but i guess you figured it out.

straightedge letter jackets are what it's all about. i used to have one... and it was even a champion brand... but this girl who was my roommate stole it and took off the letters.

ps: do you know mike mcternan..and is if so is he still edge? last time i saw him was probably 94 or 95 ish... at the rate he was going then he is probably 100% tattooed now.

yeah. he was involved in opening jinx proof here, I think just so he wouldn't have to pay anymore. last time I saw/talked to him he was, but that was probably a good 3 years now.

xvunderx
10-22-2003, 09:16 AM
Ypu do know if you want such jackets I can make it happen right?

flame_still_burns
10-22-2003, 09:24 AM
Originally posted by xvunderx
Ypu do know if you want suck jackets I cna make it happen right?

my viv to english translator is down right now... can you resubmit this?

suck jackets?

xvunderx
10-22-2003, 09:42 AM
Originally posted by flame_still_burns
my viv to english translator is down right now... can you resubmit this?

suck jackets?

Thats not english, thats what happesn when I dont look at the screen when I type....Such jackets.

I didn;t inherrit my mums typing skills

flame_still_burns
10-22-2003, 09:45 AM
Originally posted by xvunderx
Thats not english, thats what happesn when I dont look at the screen when I type....Such jackets.

I didn;t inherrit my mums typing skills

i'd be all about such jackets.

the thing with such jackets they tend to be costly...

xvunderx
10-22-2003, 09:48 AM
Originally posted by flame_still_burns
i'd be all about such jackets.

the thing with such jackets they tend to be costly...

Unless it's a DIY effort.

littlegirlblue
11-02-2003, 05:59 PM
mxpx



***hahahaha just kidding*** waits for gunshots...
naw, just kidding. I thought I'd break in my newness with a joke.
You aren't laughing are you?

xsecx
11-03-2003, 12:22 PM
Originally posted by littlegirlblue
mxpx



***hahahaha just kidding*** waits for gunshots...
naw, just kidding. I thought I'd break in my newness with a joke.
You aren't laughing are you?

what's actually funny is that there are people that will believe you.

Munncha
11-03-2003, 03:16 PM
Originally posted by littlegirlblue
mxpx



***hahahaha just kidding*** waits for gunshots...
naw, just kidding. I thought I'd break in my newness with a joke.
You aren't laughing are you?

omg like, they're straightedge and they love jesus. I'm straightedge and i love jesus! I'd totally bang them though, you know? Just them though.

xsecx
11-03-2003, 03:18 PM
Originally posted by Munncha
omg like, they're straightedge and they love jesus. I'm straightedge and i love jesus! I'd totally bang them though, you know? Just them though.

let he who knows much about hardcore,say the first condesending thing. let he who knows nothing of hardcore, shut his pie hole.

Munncha
11-03-2003, 03:19 PM
Originally posted by xsecx
let he who knows much about hardcore,say the first condesending thing. let he who knows nothing of hardcore, shut his pie hole.

Hah. fair enough. They're still dreamy....

I know of good hardcore, too bad there's such a small amount of it. But i digress...

xsecx
11-03-2003, 03:21 PM
Originally posted by Munncha
Hah. fair enough. They're still dreamy....

I know of good hardcore, too bad there's such a small amount of it. But i digress...

talking out of your ass on things you know little about appears to be your speciality. I think I'm going to change your user title to pacifist boy.

Munncha
11-03-2003, 03:23 PM
Originally posted by xsecx
talking out of your ass on things you know little about appears to be your speciality. I think I'm going to change your user title to pacifist boy.

BAD ASS! Do i have to use it to sign in?

xsecx
11-03-2003, 03:29 PM
Originally posted by Munncha
BAD ASS! Do i have to use it to sign in?

user title made more sense.

Baby Doll
11-05-2003, 11:00 AM
converge
walls of jericho
undying
eighteen visions
morning again


and more, where not everyone is sXe...

xsecx
11-05-2003, 11:01 AM
Originally posted by Baby Doll
converge
walls of jericho
undying
eighteen visions
morning again


and more, where not everyone is sXe...

I'm pretty sure none of those are "straight edge bands".We're doing a master list of bands that claim to be straight edge bands, not just have straight edge members.

resistancecrime
11-06-2003, 12:48 PM
Damn what happened to the list? Well here's my input:
One King Down
Horizon
Over and Out
Extinction
point of no Return
Far from Breaking
Risen
Shit...everything from Catalyst
Nueva Etica

resistancecrime
11-07-2003, 12:15 AM
Originally posted by resistancecrime
Damn what happened to the list? Well here's my input:
One King Down
Horizon
Over and Out
Extinction
point of no Return
Far from Breaking
Risen
Shit...everything from Catalyst
Nueva Etica
And to ass to that:
xForever Truex
crossingpoint
Reprisal
Fuerza X

resistancecrime
11-07-2003, 12:23 PM
Originally posted by resistancecrime
And to ass to that:
xForever Truex
crossingpoint
Reprisal
Fuerza X
Yipes! I meant add not "ass". A couple more bands:
In your face
Wear the mark

X-michael-X
11-10-2003, 12:45 PM
i've got some bands to .some of them are from belgium.

XkombatX,
theXdeal,
lastXstraw,
deadXreconing,
zeroXtolerance,
XcanaanX,
XthrowdownX,
XdeadlockX,
lastXstraw,

don't know anny more right now

straightXed
11-10-2003, 01:29 PM
Originally posted by X-michael-X
i've got some bands to .some of them are from belgium.

XkombatX,
theXdeal,
lastXstraw,
deadXreconing,
zeroXtolerance,
XcanaanX,
XthrowdownX,
XdeadlockX,
lastXstraw,

don't know anny more right now

you forgot lastXstraw

face_yourself
12-21-2003, 03:12 PM
Is From Autumn to Ashes considered a straight-edge band?

straightXed
12-21-2003, 04:48 PM
Originally posted by face_yourself
Is From Autumn to Ashes considered a straight-edge band?

Not straightedge and some would say not even a band!

flame_still_burns
12-21-2003, 05:18 PM
i'll add the band that is on my playlist in heavy rotation:

A.18

Chance301
12-31-2003, 05:02 AM
xlooking forwardx
carol
xuntil the endx
those who remain
down to nothing
count me out

xsecx
03-10-2004, 05:24 PM
top

XXX MIKE XXX
03-11-2004, 06:52 AM
All Bets Off
Bold
Quicksand
Civ
Lakeside Riot
Skamkroftna (sp.. germany)











oh! and... Anti-flag :D *waves to Linsee*

xsecx
03-11-2004, 07:07 AM
Originally posted by XXX MIKE XXX
All Bets Off
Bold
Quicksand
Civ
Lakeside Riot
Skamkroftna (sp.. germany)











oh! and... Anti-flag :D *waves to Linsee*

how are quicksand or civ edge bands?

Riki
03-23-2004, 10:18 AM
i hate to say it but lost prophets try to market themselves as an sXe band. (maybe market is the operative word).

xsecx
03-23-2004, 10:32 AM
Originally posted by Riki
i hate to say it but lost prophets try to market themselves as an sXe band. (maybe market is the operative word).

do you know where anything is that says this?

Riki
03-23-2004, 04:00 PM
From the lost prophets official website. (http://lostprophets.intheuk.com/)



What is Straight Edge? How many of the prophets are straight edge?
Straight edge means that the individual does not smoke, drink alcohol, take recreational drugs or divulge in promiscuous sex. It can also mean the individual is vegetarian or vegan, but in the prophets case, they all eat meat. Ian, Mike L and Lee are the straight-edgers. All three used to wear X's on the backs of their hands, Mike used to have a straight edge sticker on one of his guitars. They can still be seen wearing DARE t-shirts.
Stu and Jamie still drink alcohol, and Mike C has just supposedly quit drinking.


id hardly say they are helping the hardcore scene with there music but mneh...

straightXed
03-23-2004, 04:05 PM
Originally posted by Riki
From the lost prophets official website. (http://lostprophets.intheuk.com/)



id hardly say they are helping the hardcore scene with there music but mneh...

Lost prophets are fucking crap, like really really crap.

xsecx
03-23-2004, 04:15 PM
Originally posted by Riki
From the lost prophets official website. (http://lostprophets.intheuk.com/)



id hardly say they are helping the hardcore scene with there music but mneh...

no different than AFI or glassjaw.

xsecx
03-23-2004, 04:16 PM
Originally posted by straightXed
Lost prophets are fucking crap, like really really crap.


dragon vs ed!

Riki
03-23-2004, 04:27 PM
Originally posted by xsecx
no different than AFI or glassjaw.

Davey havoc doesnt really pimp up his sXe opinions tho, he answers when asks, but as far as i know doesnt bring it up on his own.

xsecx
03-23-2004, 05:47 PM
Originally posted by Riki
Davey havoc doesnt really pimp up his sXe opinions tho, he answers when asks, but as far as i know doesnt bring it up on his own.

he had kids X up in videos and as a result a bunch of AFI fans mimic it without knowing anything about it.

straightXed
03-24-2004, 03:05 AM
Originally posted by xsecx
dragon vs ed!

dragon fly perhaps?

Riki
03-24-2004, 10:07 AM
Originally posted by xsecx
no different than AFI or glassjaw.


or NOFX.

xsecx
03-24-2004, 10:16 AM
Originally posted by Riki
or NOFX.

how do they factor in?

Riki
03-24-2004, 10:28 AM
Be nice to me....


Back in the old days 3 members of NOFX where all sXe.


i just wanted 2 feel part of discussion :'(

xsecx
03-24-2004, 10:31 AM
Originally posted by Riki
Be nice to me....


Back in the old days 3 members of NOFX where all sXe.


i just wanted 2 feel part of discussion :'(

oh it isn't that, just seem to have came out of nowhere. like we were talking about lost prophets andthen afi and glassjaw and then nofx, just didn't make any sense.

but yeah. depending on the day of the week and where you read it, the NOFX history changes pretty dramatically so I wouldn't put too much faith in the things you've heard. especially since one of the NOFX name rumors is that it meant No fucking straight edge.

Riki
03-24-2004, 09:02 PM
I thought nofx came as a cheap rip of the band Negative FX, and it was NOFX cos they where "pure punk" without gimics... (apparently).

Anywho i read the sXe thing in erik melvins *memoirs* i think... buth mneh ur probobly right :)

Straightedgecat
04-15-2004, 02:17 PM
Originally posted by Baby Doll
converge
walls of jericho
undying
eighteen visions
morning again


and more, where not everyone is sXe...


arnt bassicly all of those bands that you listen on Trustkill records.. and none of those bands that you mentioned were sXe bands.. and since you were nameing Trustkill bands.. you forgot to mention Throwdown, and thye are actually a Straight Edge band on Trustkill..

xJoeyNormalx
05-18-2004, 01:19 AM
XheadwalkX

And, in NZ:
Evil Priest (although George, the drummer, broke Edge...and was replaced by a non-Edge drummer)
One Must Fall (...drug free for Christ, not specifically Edge)
Brick vs Face (ditto)

xsecx
06-21-2004, 08:57 AM
with honor

suicidalXeleven
06-25-2004, 03:08 AM
Alright, im new here, i've been reading, and.. i to go to the topic, i thought this was about the bands, hardcore bands to be exact, and for anyone who says LOST PROPHETS is hardcore... burn in hell seriously.. and you know being 'edge' is gay.. its just another name for.. 'hippy' you know? the faggots who hugged trees and care about life so precious.. ya well i got one thing to say.. GO FUCK YOURSELF HIPPIES ya thats write.. i said it, now another thing, is sXe not about anti-obession? am i right? i believe so. so.. now.. to my next point, would YOU being OBESSES with sXe not defeat the purpose? and formy final statement... GO HUG SOME TREES HIPPIES

straightXed
06-25-2004, 03:33 AM
Originally posted by suicidalXeleven
Alright, im new here, i've been reading, and.. i to go to the topic, i thought this was about the bands, hardcore bands to be exact, and for anyone who says LOST PROPHETS is hardcore... burn in hell seriously.. and you know being 'edge' is gay.. its just another name for.. 'hippy' you know? the faggots who hugged trees and care about life so precious.. ya well i got one thing to say.. GO FUCK YOURSELF HIPPIES ya thats write.. i said it, now another thing, is sXe not about anti-obession? am i right? i believe so. so.. now.. to my next point, would YOU being OBESSES with sXe not defeat the purpose? and formy final statement... GO HUG SOME TREES HIPPIES

congratulations on getting this far in life with your head up your ass and your vision impaired because you have your own shit in your eyes. Talking of shit, when you try to talk shit you should try to make it accurate and not just incoherent babble unless you are going for dumb fuck of the year award.

xsecx
06-25-2004, 08:03 AM
Originally posted by suicidalXeleven
Alright, im new here, i've been reading, and.. i to go to the topic, i thought this was about the bands, hardcore bands to be exact, and for anyone who says LOST PROPHETS is hardcore... burn in hell seriously.. and you know being 'edge' is gay.. its just another name for.. 'hippy' you know? the faggots who hugged trees and care about life so precious.. ya well i got one thing to say.. GO FUCK YOURSELF HIPPIES ya thats write.. i said it, now another thing, is sXe not about anti-obession? am i right? i believe so. so.. now.. to my next point, would YOU being OBESSES with sXe not defeat the purpose? and formy final statement... GO HUG SOME TREES HIPPIES

didn't you get the memo that suicide isn't cool and that you're an idiot?

disturbed rose
06-25-2004, 11:20 AM
Did you also get the memo that this site is called www.SXE.com?

XrandomideazX
06-25-2004, 11:34 AM
He made all the effort....to.......never mind.Im glad you came to sXe.com gives us another dumbass to point and make fun of!You do know any statment you make will just be void so.....DIE

DoglikeSpleen
06-25-2004, 11:40 AM
hey nothing wrong with liking the environment and shit like that either right?? Im not a member of the green party for nothing... call me a hippie if you must, i like the walflowers, pink floyd, and a ton of other ooooold school 'hippie' music..

XrandomideazX
06-25-2004, 03:09 PM
the walflowers?are you serious?I havent heard about them in ages!They suck anyway

straightXed
06-25-2004, 04:30 PM
Originally posted by DoglikeSpleen
hey nothing wrong with liking the environment and shit like that either right?? Im not a member of the green party for nothing... call me a hippie if you must, i like the walflowers, pink floyd, and a ton of other ooooold school 'hippie' music..

hippies are bread heads man.

xJoeyNormalx
06-28-2004, 04:39 AM
George no longer drums for the Priest.

There's also Brick vs Face.

xgregx
06-30-2004, 11:25 AM
Undying

painplusone
07-08-2004, 04:11 PM
www.truetilldeath.com has a pretty good list, not a complete one but still pretty good

xdaddydaycorex
10-21-2004, 06:58 PM
proclamation

slinkysRrad
10-26-2004, 02:31 PM
Originally posted by xsecx
yeah davey is.

JADE IS TOO!

slinkysRrad
10-26-2004, 02:44 PM
All the bands I was gonnalist are listed accept The Action Taken. They're a local band... they still count, right?

xdaddydaycorex
11-11-2004, 05:40 PM
Minor Threat
Gorilla Biscuits
Youth of Today
Slapshot
Judge
Floorpunch
Ten yard fight
bloodpact
wide awake
ssd
dys
uniform choice
atari
strife
undertow
brotherhood
turning point
mouthpiece
with honor
unbroken
mean season
insted
lifetime
ressurection
earth crisis
project x
no for an answer
chain of strength
outspoken
release
bold
champion
stay gold
over my dead body
25 ta life
carry nation
stand and fight
commitment
battery
chorus of disapproval
blade crasher
count me out
embrace today
fastbreak
xForever Truex
crossingpoint
Reprisal
Fuerza X
XkombatX,
theXdeal,
lastXstraw,
deadXreconing,
zeroXtolerance,
XcanaanX,
XthrowdownX,
XdeadlockX,
lastXstrawno reply
One King Down
Horizon
Over and Out
Extinction
point of no Return
Far from Breaking
Risen
unity
crucial youth
A18
underdog
xlooking forwardx
carol
xuntil the endx
those who remain
down to nothing
count me out
undyingunity
monster x
up front
crucial youth
side by side
unit pride
97a
proclamation
time x

straightXed
11-11-2004, 06:55 PM
why did you leave time X off?

xdaddydaycorex
11-12-2004, 11:21 AM
Originally posted by straightXed
why did you leave time X off?
mistake. it's back.

the list so far:

Minor Threat
Gorilla Biscuits
Youth of Today
Slapshot
Judge
Floorpunch
Ten yard fight
bloodpact
wide awake
ssd
dys
uniform choice
atari
strife
undertow
brotherhood
turning point
mouthpiece
with honor
unbroken
mean season
insted
lifetime
ressurection
earth crisis
project x
no for an answer
chain of strength
outspoken
release
bold
champion
stay gold
over my dead body
25 ta life
carry nation
stand and fight
commitment
battery
chorus of disapproval
blade crasher
count me out
embrace today
fastbreak
xForever Truex
crossingpoint
Reprisal
Fuerza X
XkombatX,
theXdeal,
lastXstraw,
deadXreconing,
zeroXtolerance,
XcanaanX,
XthrowdownX,
XdeadlockX,
lastXstrawno reply
One King Down
Horizon
Over and Out
Extinction
point of no Return
Far from Breaking
Risen
unity
crucial youth
A18
underdog
xlooking forwardx
carol
xuntil the endx
those who remain
down to nothing
count me out
undyingunity
monster x
up front
crucial youth
side by side
unit pride
97a
proclamation
time x
the promise

XAngry CodgerX
01-22-2005, 12:01 AM
Heres a couple more -

Infest - Straightedge grindcore.
Chokehold - Canadian Vegan Sxe
Unconquered - Reno Straightedge
XClearX - SLC SXE
Lifeless - SLC Vegan SXE
Excessive Force - Orange County SxE
First Blood - Sacto Ca
Sworn Vengeance - Vacaville CA
One Life Crew - Clevo

xsecx
01-22-2005, 08:20 AM
Heres a couple more -

Infest - Straightedge grindcore.
Chokehold - Canadian Vegan Sxe
Unconquered - Reno Straightedge
XClearX - SLC SXE
Lifeless - SLC Vegan SXE
Excessive Force - Orange County SxE
First Blood - Sacto Ca
Sworn Vengeance - Vacaville CA
One Life Crew - Clevo
olc wasn't edge.

XAngry CodgerX
01-22-2005, 03:32 PM
olc wasn't edge.

Dude do we have to argue about this too? You could be correct, I was under the assumption that they were, as the One Life Crew was a straightedge crew in Cleveland. I'll get back to you.

xsecx
01-22-2005, 03:38 PM
Dude do we have to argue about this too? You could be correct, I was under the assumption that they were, as the One Life Crew was a straightedge crew in Cleveland. I'll get back to you.
they smoked cigars. they were a joke band to some extent. just like pitboss.

and you're right the crew was. just like the ek's were also a crew from there at the same time. the band existed after the crew though and did some none edge stuff.

xx_sXe_xx
02-15-2005, 10:58 AM
don't forget the Teen Idols...minor threat minus a person...forget who though

xsecx
02-15-2005, 11:10 AM
don't forget the Teen Idols...minor threat minus a person...forget who though
teen idles only have 2 guys from minor threat.

MidnightHours
04-27-2005, 12:57 AM
he had kids X up in videos and as a result a bunch of AFI fans mimic it without knowing anything about it.

If your talking about the leaving song part 2 video then.... the person at the start of the video putting on the x's was a fan that had met them a few times already and always went to the shows so they put him in the video. He posted on afi's message board about it before. I'm pretty sure hes the only one they show doing it and I think that he is edge(having trouble trying to remember that one). A lot of the younger fans probably did start to mimic it but he's older and probably knew what he was doing.

On an ealier post in this thread...yes jade is also sxe. Him and Davey are alike in a few different things and close friends(People have come to call them "javey" because of that).

I'm way off topic I know....just thought had that on my mind.

xboodyx
05-17-2005, 01:47 PM
the only other one i know of is win the fight
theyre a local band

XcaitieXchaos
06-02-2005, 12:54 AM
minor threat for sure.

My best friend likes XCanaanX a whole lot, anyone listen to that?

straightXed
06-02-2005, 01:55 AM
minor threat for sure.

My best friend likes XCanaanX a whole lot, anyone listen to that?

they split a few years back, check out on thin ice and Xthe break inX

XcaitieXchaos
06-03-2005, 12:38 AM
they split a few years back, check out on thin ice and Xthe break inX


Thanks, I didn't feel like doing my own research.

straightXed
06-03-2005, 02:14 AM
Thanks, I didn't feel like doing my own research.

lazy

keithxXx
07-09-2005, 05:41 PM
alright im gonna add 2 more.. and im very suprised that there not on here since there 2 of my all time favorite bands
Casey Jones
and
xDEATHSTARx http://xdeathstarx.com/music.php

2 awesome bands that you definately need to listen 2
and
death before dishonor another awesome band

XuntaintdbloodX
07-11-2005, 03:44 PM
Is From Autumn to Ashes considered a straight-edge band?

do people just ask some kid for the title of a hardcore band and then use it to start conversation, i'm ussually not mean but why would someone even think they are straightedge, i dont even consider them hardcore, emocore

XuntaintdbloodX
07-11-2005, 03:49 PM
congratulations on getting this far in life with your head up your ass and your vision impaired because you have your own shit in your eyes. Talking of shit, when you try to talk shit you should try to make it accurate and not just incoherent babble unless you are going for dumb fuck of the year award.


i say congratualtions on wasting your time creating a username just to bash the other users

XuntaintdbloodX
07-11-2005, 03:58 PM
alright im gonna add 2 more.. and im very suprised that there not on here since there 2 of my all time favorite bands
Casey Jones
and
xDEATHSTARx http://xdeathstarx.com/music.php

2 awesome bands that you definately need to listen 2
and
death before dishonor another awesome band

i was wating till the last post to say casey jones... you bastard!!!! yeah and i'm surprised no one said himsa arent they straight edge? xdiscplex AD and they're new band jesus wept is probably straight edge since it has alot of members from xdisciplex AD, a perfect murder, bleeding through too. xone fifthx a side project with evergreen terrace i thought they were straight edge too but i guess not so all the edge members must have done side projects cause casey jones has members of evergreen terrace too.

XuntaintdbloodX
07-11-2005, 04:00 PM
obviously i heart scene points... give em to me!!!

keithxXx
07-11-2005, 04:34 PM
im to quick for you./

XuntaintdbloodX
07-12-2005, 08:19 AM
im to quick for you./

well for all these true hardcore kids that dispise metalcore casey jones is a good band i like em alot but i also like metalcore as well as real hardcore... my friend read a rewiew on casey jones and it said they were metalcore cause he screams and not yells even though the insturmental isnt metal...

XuntaintdbloodX
07-12-2005, 08:20 AM
alright im gonna add 2 more.. and im very suprised that there not on here since there 2 of my all time favorite bands
Casey Jones
and
xDEATHSTARx http://xdeathstarx.com/music.php

2 awesome bands that you definately need to listen 2
and
death before dishonor another awesome band

i've never heard of xdeathstarx what bands do they sound like... casey jones?

Negative K
08-29-2005, 07:18 PM
Minor Threat
7 Seconds
SS Decontrol
Unity
Uniform Choice
DYS
YOT
Gorilla Biscuits
Inside Out
Chain
eXc

the classics

keithxXx
08-29-2005, 11:58 PM
i've never heard of xdeathstarx what bands do they sound like... casey jones?
HAHAHA not even close !!!! they are hard as fuck... i think they got a myspace... myspace.com/xdeathstarx

xFallenChancesGonex
11-14-2005, 01:47 PM
now might be a good time to start forming a master list of sxe bands.
first person to say anti flag gets a nutsack.

*My sister and I were talking, and looking up sxe bands, and this is what we found*
7 seconds
25 Ta Life
A Chorus of Disapproval
Abusive Action
Amendment 18
As We Fight
Bold
Burden
xCanaanx
Carry On
Cast Aside
Chain Of Strength
Champion
Congress
Contempt
Count Me Out
Culture
Die Hard Youth
DYS
Earth Crisis
Empathy
Floorpunch
Give Up The Ghost
Good Clean Fun
Gorilla Biscuts
Government Issue
Heaven Shall Burn
In My Eyes
Insted
Judge
Kindred
Make Move
Mental
Morning Again
Most Precious Blood
My Revenge
Outspoken
Over My Dead Body
Project X
Racetraitor
Regression
Rise Against
Reaching Forward
Refused
Reprisal
Shelter
Side By Side
Slapshot
Solid
Spirit 84
Spirit Of Youth
Sportswear
SSD
Still Crossed
Strife
The Deal
The Promise
Throwdown
Time Flies
Trial
Unbroken
Uniform Choice
Unity
With Honor
xInvictusx
xMaroonx Youth Of Today

xsecx
11-14-2005, 03:59 PM
*My sister and I were talking, and looking up sxe bands, and this is what we found*
25 Ta Life
Give Up The Ghost
Mental
Racetraitor
Shelter


these aren't/weren't

xGriffox
11-14-2005, 05:13 PM
charles bronson :D

Know This |X|
12-13-2005, 03:45 PM
I think ...


Love is Red?

xRodboi!x
12-26-2005, 04:24 PM
minor threat
refused
kid dynamite
casey jones
reaching forward
ten yard fight
warzone
champion
youth of today
25 ta life
judge
gorilla biscuits
vitamin x
good clean fun
bold
slapshot
7seconds :for the most importants i know

xRodboi!x
12-26-2005, 04:28 PM
i forgot earth crisis

xsecx
12-28-2005, 04:29 PM
minor threat
refused
kid dynamite
casey jones
reaching forward
ten yard fight
warzone
champion
youth of today
25 ta life
judge
gorilla biscuits
vitamin x
good clean fun
bold
slapshot
7seconds :for the most importants i know

kid dynamite wassn't. warzone wasn't. 25 ta life arent.

xRodboi!x
01-03-2006, 12:44 PM
kid dynamite wassn't. warzone wasn't. 25 ta life arent.
i thought 25 ta life were coz i thought rick was sxe.25 ta life can be considered as a one man band.I forgot Battery and Better than a thousand

xsecx
01-03-2006, 12:52 PM
i thought 25 ta life were coz i thought rick was sxe.25 ta life can be considered as a one man band.I forgot Battery and Better than a thousand

he is, but the rest ofthe band isn't.

SgtD
01-03-2006, 01:36 PM
he is, but the rest ofthe band isn't.
i always thought he was a druggie

straight sam
01-03-2006, 04:20 PM
now might be a good time to start forming a master list of sxe bands.
first person to say anti flag gets a nutsack.

don´t you like them?

xsecx
01-03-2006, 06:17 PM
don´t you like them?

no, but regardless, they're not an edge band.

straight sam
01-04-2006, 03:55 PM
no, but regardless, they're not an edge band.

hmm... but they say so ? I don´t know, don´t wanna say somethin

SgtD
01-05-2006, 05:15 AM
hmm... but they say so ? I don´t know, don´t wanna say somethin
do they?

straight sam
01-05-2006, 03:26 PM
I heard so...

kaytee187x
02-19-2006, 05:39 PM
eighteen visions is
they've said it in interviews

and xRAINx

straightXed
02-19-2006, 05:58 PM
eighteen visions is
they've said it in interviews



Definitely not what i would call hardcore.

xbustedx
02-19-2006, 06:13 PM
Minor Threat
Youth Of Today
(early)glassJAw
xbustedx
Sons Of Abraham
Slapeshot
Throwdown

SgtD
02-20-2006, 02:17 AM
Minor Threat
Youth Of Today
(early)glassJAw
xbustedx
Sons Of Abraham
Slapeshot
Throwdown
busted?

xbustedx
02-20-2006, 01:31 PM
busted?

yeah it was a small sxe band out of Long Island NY.

SgtD
02-20-2006, 03:19 PM
yeah it was a small sxe band out of Long Island NY.
that name isn't too good pick

xbustedx
02-20-2006, 05:54 PM
that name isn't too good pick


can you please make sure your grammar was correct please. Because I didn't understand what you said.

straightXed
02-20-2006, 06:16 PM
can you please make sure your grammar was correct please. Because I didn't understand what you said.

Its not a good name to pick would be what i thought he was getting at.

SgtD
02-21-2006, 02:19 AM
can you please make sure your grammar was correct please. Because I didn't understand what you said.
what Ed said

xsecx
02-21-2006, 08:45 AM
Minor Threat
Youth Of Today
(early)glassJAw
xbustedx
Sons Of Abraham
Slapeshot
Throwdown

I'm pretty sure glassjaw was never a straight edge band. throwdown is also currently questionable. historically yes, but now it's not quite as clear.

mouseman004
02-21-2006, 11:33 AM
I'm pretty sure glassjaw was never a straight edge band. throwdown is also currently questionable. historically yes, but now it's not quite as clear.


As far as I know, Throwdown are still an edge band, even with the new members they are all edge. They were talking about it in the DVD that came with Vendetta, so unless things have changed since that release i think they are still edge.

xsecx
02-21-2006, 11:47 AM
As far as I know, Throwdown are still an edge band, even with the new members they are all edge. They were talking about it in the DVD that came with Vendetta, so unless things have changed since that release i think they are still edge.

there's no mention of it anywhere in the band bio. band website went from xthrowdownx.com to throwdowngo.com, etc.

xbustedx
02-22-2006, 09:16 AM
I'm pretty sure glassjaw was never a straight edge band. throwdown is also currently questionable. historically yes, but now it's not quite as clear.

glassJAw was a sxe when it first started.

xbustedx
02-22-2006, 09:16 AM
although your correct it didn't last long.

and as far as I know Throwdown Is stil sxe.

xsecx
02-22-2006, 10:05 AM
glassJAw was a sxe when it first started.

what are you basing this on?

xsecx
02-22-2006, 10:06 AM
although your correct it didn't last long.

and as far as I know Throwdown Is stil sxe.

people in the band might be, but that doesn't mean they're still promoting or calling themselves a straight edge band. there is a difference.

mouseman004
02-22-2006, 11:26 AM
i would definately assume that throwdown is still edge because they still sell edge merchandise and they put at least one straight edge song on every album. I agree that they are promoting it less now but I would say they are still and edge band

xsecx
02-22-2006, 11:51 AM
i would definately assume that throwdown is still edge because they still sell edge merchandise and they put at least one straight edge song on every album. I agree that they are promoting it less now but I would say they are still and edge band

selling stuff because it makes them money and being a band with edge people in it , vs being a straight edge band are 2 different things.

mouseman004
02-22-2006, 01:00 PM
selling stuff because it makes them money and being a band with edge people in it , vs being a straight edge band are 2 different things.


They can sell non edge merchandise and make just as much money. my point is, they would probably not be selling shirts that say "Throwdown: Straight Edge" if they were not an edge band

xsecx
02-22-2006, 01:05 PM
They can sell non edge merchandise and make just as much money. my point is, they would probably not be selling shirts that say "Throwdown: Straight Edge" if they were not an edge band

then if that's the case, then why change the website and why not even include in your band bio?

xbustedx
02-23-2006, 10:00 PM
what are you basing this on?

conversations I have had with Daryl Palumbo (lead singer)

xsecx
02-24-2006, 08:41 AM
conversations I have had with Daryl Palumbo (lead singer)

even so, they never put out a straight edge record, and were never a straight edge band. they may have intended to be at the beginning but never were.

xbustedx
02-24-2006, 10:20 AM
even so, they never put out a straight edge record, and were never a straight edge band. they may have intended to be at the beginning but never were.

They were playing sxe music. Long before they ever put out an album. Your right they never put out a sxe album. But they were a sxe band.

xsecx
02-24-2006, 10:23 AM
They were playing sxe music. Long before they ever put out an album. Your right they never put out a sxe album. But they were a sxe band.

sure thing dude, but in the scheme of things and in relative terms, they weren't and shouldn't be included in discussions of straight edge bands if the extent of their time as an edge band was early on and never recorded.

xbustedx
02-24-2006, 10:26 AM
sure thing dude, but in the scheme of things and in relative terms, they weren't and shouldn't be included in discussions of straight edge bands if the extent of their time as an edge band was early on and never recorded.

if you say so. but I don't think that we should exclude discussing sxe bands just because they were never recorded. But its your forum and yoru rules. So, understood.

xsecx
02-24-2006, 10:28 AM
if you say so. but I don't think that we should exclude discussing sxe bands just because they were never recorded. But its your forum and yoru rules. So, understood.

if a tree falls in the forest, does it make a sound? How much impact is a band going to have in terms of edge if people don't hear the songs, aren't played and were never recorded?

xbustedx
02-24-2006, 10:37 AM
if a tree falls in the forest, does it make a sound? How much impact is a band going to have in terms of edge if people don't hear the songs, aren't played and were never recorded?

thats not true I am sure lots of people hear bands long before they record anything. And I am sure that they have impacts on their own sxe community.

xsecx
02-24-2006, 10:46 AM
thats not true I am sure lots of people hear bands long before they record anything. And I am sure that they have impacts on their own sxe community.

hearing them and them having an impact aren't the same thing. with this case in point, when people talk about and think about glassjaw it's not to do with straight edge at all, because they had no impact on the scene or the movement in general.

Ahab
03-04-2006, 11:18 PM
Not to interrupt, but xNeverxAgainx, Suffocate Faster, xTyrantx.
Sorry if they've already been listed, I didn't want to go through every page of this thread.

xbustedx
03-04-2006, 11:51 PM
hearing them and them having an impact aren't the same thing. with this case in point, when people talk about and think about glassjaw it's not to do with straight edge at all, because they had no impact on the scene or the movement in general.

I bet people that heard them when they were sxe still discuss them on the topic of sxe.

xsecx
03-05-2006, 08:25 AM
I bet people that heard them when they were sxe still discuss them on the topic of sxe.

so a handful of people in a specific point in time that didn't last very long. that's not impact dude.

xbustedx
03-05-2006, 01:44 PM
so a handful of people in a specific point in time that didn't last very long. that's not impact dude.


it made an impact on them. and so what? if it didn't impact the Entire sxe community? Is it any less worth discussing?

xsecx
03-05-2006, 01:59 PM
it made an impact on them. and so what? if it didn't impact the Entire sxe community? Is it any less worth discussing?

it didn't have an impact on anyone. The only reason you know about it based on conversations with people in the band, nothing else. That's not impact. It wasn't worth it to them to continue being a straight edge band except for an extremely short amount of time, so why is it worth discussing? Should we also include every band that played a show, or even met but never played?

xbustedx
03-05-2006, 09:43 PM
it didn't have an impact on anyone. The only reason you know about it based on conversations with people in the band, nothing else. That's not impact. It wasn't worth it to them to continue being a straight edge band except for an extremely short amount of time, so why is it worth discussing? Should we also include every band that played a show, or even met but never played?

but they DID play your acting as if they never played a song.

xsecx
03-06-2006, 06:19 AM
but they DID play your acting as if they never played a song.

yeah. can you name their songs? can you give us all lyrics?

xbustedx
03-06-2006, 09:19 AM
yeah. can you name their songs? can you give us all lyrics?


I could if you gave me a day or two.

xsecx
03-06-2006, 09:26 AM
I could if you gave me a day or two. not much of a point if you can't do it off the top of your head and have to go ask people about it. that just illustrates the point.

kelly
03-06-2006, 10:34 AM
this doesn't seem much like a list anymore...

xbustedx
03-06-2006, 08:46 PM
not much of a point if you can't do it off the top of your head and have to go ask people about it. that just illustrates the point.


There's loads of bands that I can't remember lyrics from that have been recorded.

xsecx
03-06-2006, 08:49 PM
There's loads of bands that I can't remember lyrics from that have been recorded.

difference being is that you've got something you could reference. seriously do you really think glassjaw is important in terms of straight edge on any level?

xGriffox
03-07-2006, 09:01 PM
back on topic,
Ed gein

xsecx
03-07-2006, 09:09 PM
back on topic,
Ed gein

what makes you think they're edge?

stepinsideissue
03-08-2006, 02:03 AM
Better topic GB.

collin
03-08-2006, 10:05 AM
Eighteen Visions

straightXed
03-08-2006, 10:25 AM
Eighteen Visions

further proof of poor taste

collin
03-08-2006, 10:36 AM
further proof of poor taste
I never said they were good, but they are edge.

xCAMIx
03-08-2006, 10:44 AM
xLOOKING FORWARDx
I think Ruiner Is edge.
Anyone say Good Clean Fun yet?
Crucial Youth
Slapshot
Betrayed
Champion
AFI
BOLD
Terror
Most Precious Blood (Old)
Refused (I know I'm gonna take some shit for that)
Make Your Stand
In My Way
Redemption 87
xDEATH STARx

xsecx
03-08-2006, 10:49 AM
xLOOKING FORWARDx
I think Ruiner Is edge.
Anyone say Good Clean Fun yet?
Crucial Youth
Slapshot
Betrayed
Champion
AFI
BOLD
Terror
Most Precious Blood (Old)
Refused (I know I'm gonna take some shit for that)
Make Your Stand
In My Way
Redemption 87
xDEATH STARx
afi, terror, redemption, crucial youth. not ege. terror and crucial youth, about as far from edge as you can get.

straightXed
03-08-2006, 10:52 AM
I never said they were good, but they are edge.

This is a master list and besides they were already entered and i believe rejected.

collin
03-08-2006, 10:57 AM
This is a master list and besides they were already entered and i believe rejected.
ok. sorry i didn't go through all 12 pages.

straightXed
03-08-2006, 11:21 AM
ok. sorry i didn't go through all 12 pages.

Why not?

collin
03-08-2006, 11:24 AM
Why not?
dial up is really f****ing slow...

straightXed
03-08-2006, 11:34 AM
dial up is really f****ing slow...

Weak excuse, just admit you are lazy.

collin
03-08-2006, 12:17 PM
Weak excuse, just admit you are lazy.
nah, just didn't want to wait the loading time....

straightXed
03-08-2006, 03:29 PM
nah, just didn't want to wait the loading time....

Lazy.

xCAMIx
03-08-2006, 07:04 PM
afi, terror, redemption, crucial youth. not ege. terror and crucial youth, about as far from edge as you can get.
Since when was xCxYx not edge?
And whats the deal w. Terror?
Afi is half straight edge (and maybe half straight haha).
I met Crucial Youth's singer, and he was edge from what I saw.

xsecx
03-08-2006, 07:08 PM
Since when was xCxYx not edge?
And whats the deal w. Terror?
Afi is half straight edge (and maybe half straight haha).
I met Crucial Youth's singer, and he was edge from what I saw.

crucial youth was a joke band making fun of straight edge. the vast majority of their members were very far from straight edge. what you saw was a cover band.

scott vogel drinks like a fish and smokes weed.

edge members don't make a band edge.

xGriffox
03-08-2006, 08:51 PM
what makes you think they're edge?
the fact they were selling straight edge patches when i last saw them and the song the marlboro man is a douche bag. So they may not be preaching about edge all that much but i am fairly certain that the 3 members are straight edge.

xsecx
03-08-2006, 08:53 PM
the fact they were selling straight edge patches when i last saw them and the song the marlboro man is a douche bag. So they may not be preaching about edge all that much but i am fairly certain that the 3 members are straight edge.
they don't promote themselves as an edge band though.

XshiXnyX
03-14-2006, 09:19 PM
hmmm

XarmedXforbattleX
(or at least I think thats how you spell it)

and dont you tell em that Hawthorne heights isnt Straightedge

( I kid, I kid)

stepinsideissue
03-16-2006, 01:54 AM
hmmm

XarmedXforbattleX
(or at least I think thats how you spell it)

and dont you tell em that Hawthorne heights isnt Straightedge

( I kid, I kid)


Or hXc or good for that matter.

xJONNYSCREAMx
03-17-2006, 12:59 PM
They make my world go round ahha.


Uh yeah... I'm going to get shit for this:
Bleeding Through is Edge. They have a few edge songs, and alot of the topics are actually straight edge related if you read into them. They promote being edge, and talk about it between songs. This isn't a matter of LIKING a band. Just if they're edge or not. And 18V is edge. Period.

fuz
04-30-2006, 07:24 PM
xWish for Wingsx
daylight curse

australian hXc of the north coast scene :)

xKennehx
05-21-2006, 10:20 AM
Several members of Fall Out Boy and New Found Glory are Straight Edge...not that they play hardcore, but that doesn't mean they don't listen to it eh? ;)

xsecx
05-21-2006, 10:28 AM
Several members of Fall Out Boy and New Found Glory are Straight Edge...not that they play hardcore, but that doesn't mean they don't listen to it eh? ;)

it does mean that they aren't edge bands though.

xKennehx
05-21-2006, 10:30 AM
it does mean that they aren't edge bands though.

I guess so.

0-9

* 108
* 7 Seconds

[edit]

A-D

* Action Taken, The
* A Fire Inside
* Anti-Flag
* xarmed for battlex
* Black My Heart
* Betrayed
* Birthright
* XbishopX
* Bleeding Through
* Bloody Sunday
* Blood for Blood
* Bold
* Boston Crew's DYS, SSD and Slapshot*Bold
* Bury Your Dead
* xCanaanx
* Carry On
* Casey Jones
* Chain Of Strength
* Champion
* Cherim
* Chokehold
* Count Me Out
* Death before dishonor
* Desperate Measures
* Destro
* Dumptruck
* DYS

Drug Test
[edit]

E-L

* Earth Crisis
* Ed Gein
* Eighteen Visions
* Embrace Today
* Floorpunch
* Gather
* Glassjaw
* Good Clean Fun
* Gorilla Biscuits
* Green Rage
* The Hostage Heart
* In My Eyes
* Internal Affairs
* Judge
* Kinetic Destruction
* Lightning War
* Limp Wrist

[edit]

M-Q

* Maroon
* Minor Threat
* Mental
* Mouthpiece
* NAS
* On Broken Wings
* One Life Crew
* Pain The Anti Drug
* Prayer For Cleansing
* Project X
* The Promise
* Purified in Blood

[edit]

R-S

* Refused
* Remembering Never
* Righteous Jams
* Rise Against
* Set Your Goals
* Second Combat - Malaysia sXe
* Side By Side
* Slapshot
* Snapcase
* Split Lip
* SSD
* Strife
* Spirit of Youth

[edit]

T-Z

* Ten Yard Fight
* Take The Field
* Throwdown
* Trial
* Triple Threat
* Trust
* Turning Point
* Unbroken
* Undertow
* Uniform Choice
* Unity
* Until The End
* Up Front
* Vegan Reich
* Verse
* The worriors
* XFilesX
* XlookingforwardX
* Youth Attack
* Youth of Today
* Young Death,The

Apologise if some have been posted. From:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_straight_edge_groups

xsecx
05-21-2006, 10:33 AM
I guess so.

0-9

* 108
* 7 Seconds

[edit]

A-D

* Action Taken, The
* A Fire Inside
* Anti-Flag
* xarmed for battlex
* Black My Heart
* Betrayed
* Birthright
* XbishopX
* Bleeding Through
* Bloody Sunday
* Blood for Blood
* Bold
* Boston Crew's DYS, SSD and Slapshot*Bold
* Bury Your Dead
* xCanaanx
* Carry On
* Casey Jones
* Chain Of Strength
* Champion
* Cherim
* Chokehold
* Count Me Out
* Death before dishonor
* Desperate Measures
* Destro
* Dumptruck
* DYS

Drug Test
[edit]

E-L

* Earth Crisis
* Ed Gein
* Eighteen Visions
* Embrace Today
* Floorpunch
* Gather
* Glassjaw
* Good Clean Fun
* Gorilla Biscuits
* Green Rage
* The Hostage Heart
* In My Eyes
* Internal Affairs
* Judge
* Kinetic Destruction
* Lightning War
* Limp Wrist

[edit]

M-Q

* Maroon
* Minor Threat
* Mental
* Mouthpiece
* NAS
* On Broken Wings
* One Life Crew
* Pain The Anti Drug
* Prayer For Cleansing
* Project X
* The Promise
* Purified in Blood

[edit]

R-S

* Refused
* Remembering Never
* Righteous Jams
* Rise Against
* Set Your Goals
* Second Combat - Malaysia sXe
* Side By Side
* Slapshot
* Snapcase
* Split Lip
* SSD
* Strife
* Spirit of Youth

[edit]

T-Z

* Ten Yard Fight
* Take The Field
* Throwdown
* Trial
* Triple Threat
* Trust
* Turning Point
* Unbroken
* Undertow
* Uniform Choice
* Unity
* Until The End
* Up Front
* Vegan Reich
* Verse
* The worriors
* XFilesX
* XlookingforwardX
* Youth Attack
* Youth of Today
* Young Death,The

Apologise if some have been posted. From:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_straight_edge_groups

a bunch of these are wrong. afi isn't. olc isn't, 7 seconds isn't, byd isn't, ed gein isn't, glassjaw isn't, refused isn't. and that's just from taking a quick look.

xKennehx
05-21-2006, 10:37 AM
a bunch of these are wrong. afi isn't. olc isn't, 7 seconds isn't, byd isn't, ed gein isn't, glassjaw isn't, refused isn't. and that's just from taking a quick look.

Glassjaw always have been. Daryl is extremely serious about it as far as I know.

straightXed
05-21-2006, 10:43 AM
Glassjaw always have been. Daryl is extremely serious about it as far as I know.

They aren't even hardcore though.

xKennehx
05-21-2006, 10:47 AM
They aren't even hardcore though.

Afaik they are classed as Post-Hardcore. But I see your point.

straightXed
05-21-2006, 10:53 AM
Afaik they are classed as Post-Hardcore. But I see your point.

Afaik?

Post-hardcore translates as really not hardcore.

xKennehx
05-21-2006, 10:56 AM
Afaik?

Post-hardcore translates as really not hardcore.

afaik = as far as I know

and gotcha ;)

xsecx
05-21-2006, 11:01 AM
Glassjaw always have been. Daryl is extremely serious about it as far as I know.

no they haven't, they never were. and daryl isn't even straight now.

xKennehx
05-21-2006, 11:04 AM
I was under the impression that drinking would aggrovate his Chron's disease. I'm not a doctor.

XBILLYX
05-21-2006, 11:07 AM
xlooking forwardx
xdeathstarx
embrace today
xfight everyonex

xsecx
05-21-2006, 11:08 AM
I was under the impression that drinking would aggrovate his Chron's disease. I'm not a doctor.

go read some interviews he's made lately.

XBILLYX
05-22-2006, 03:05 PM
Emo is homsexual?

are ok bro? why are you taking that so litheral? i dont care for emo ok.


Never a truer word said.

so your agreeing with them? iam confused you dont agree with me and about edge and christians

straightXed
05-22-2006, 03:13 PM
are ok bro? why are you taking that so litheral? i dont care for emo ok.

I don't care for homophobia and using terminology that deems homosexuality to be a negative thing.




so your agreeing with them? iam confused you dont agree with me and about edge and christians

I told you to look at what you wrote.

XBILLYX
05-22-2006, 09:46 PM
I don't care for homophobia and using terminology that deems homosexuality to be a negative thing.

thats cool iam! but they point was attacking their sex life it was the fact their no long that good or harcore post hardcoe at all.



I told you to look at what you wrote.


fighteveryone is christian to and they say that its bs you can be christians and edge.

it says can be edge and christian so your saying it is a true statemnet.

yourdoomawaitsu
05-27-2006, 02:52 PM
slapshot aren't straightedge because they ate meat.

just kidding.

turning point
mouthpiece
unbroken
mean season
insted
lifetime
ressurection
earth crisis
project x
no for an answer
chain of strength
outspoken
release
bold


just out of curiosity what's the deal with anti-flag? when i was doing shows this guy pat from that band used to call me for shows all the time...but just guessing by their name i figured they weren't quite what we were into doing. i've still never heard them...they aren't trying to be a straightedge band are they?


eating meat has nothing to do with being edge thats a vegatarian!

xsecx
05-27-2006, 04:23 PM
eating meat has nothing to do with being edge thats a vegatarian!

did you miss the just kidding part ?

CULT xXx STATUS
06-18-2006, 11:44 AM
wasnt this supposed to be about bands...?

xsecx
06-19-2006, 09:45 AM
wasnt this supposed to be about bands...?

yes it is.

hxcsxe
07-14-2006, 10:08 AM
i got the minor threat discography the other day man now that whats its albout

Tex
09-27-2006, 02:32 PM
What makes a band edge?

xaaronx
11-14-2006, 03:15 PM
What makes a band edge?

A band that contain edge members, and tend to write songs about straight edge.

xsecx
11-14-2006, 03:17 PM
A band that contain edge members, and tend to write songs about straight edge.

it essentially boils down to the same thing of what makes a person edge. If a band refers to themselves as an edge band, then they are.

mXoXsXh
11-15-2006, 11:42 AM
Too Pure To Die
Make Your Stand
XboundinbloodX
XtripwireX
XlifeXruinerX
SharkXpunch

are all good bands

is Black My Heart a sXe band? its more of a bro band

Tex
11-15-2006, 04:09 PM
A band that contain edge members, and tend to write songs about straight edge.

it essentially boils down to the same thing of what makes a person edge. If a band refers to themselves as an edge band, then they are.

thanks guys

BornAgainVirginDrugs
06-16-2007, 03:14 PM
it essentially boils down to the same thing of what makes a person edge. If a band refers to themselves as an edge band, then they are.

If being edge is a personal commitment why would a group of artists advocate "sXe" unless they have an extreme amount of edge following fans? If a band was truly about the music and not reputation then they would not claim edge. It's almost a religious-like mentality. Edge has seemed to become diluted like oil in water. I expected more from a domain name like "www.sxe.com."

Who cares if a band is "edge" or not?

As long as you can personally extract something from the band musically and lyrically, what is there left that the labels and titles can offer you?

xsecx
06-17-2007, 12:12 AM
If being edge is a personal commitment why would a group of artists advocate "sXe" unless they have an extreme amount of edge following fans? If a band was truly about the music and not reputation then they would not claim edge. It's almost a religious-like mentality. Edge has seemed to become diluted like oil in water. I expected more from a domain name like "www.sxe.com."

Who cares if a band is "edge" or not?

As long as you can personally extract something from the band musically and lyrically, what is there left that the labels and titles can offer you?

diluted compared to what, exactly? and what did you expect?

XbriX
11-29-2007, 02:31 PM
now might be a good time to start forming a master list of sxe bands.
first person to say anti flag gets a nutsack.

To say anti-flag is not considered a straight edge band is wrong. People who want to make change, for the world and themselves and bring nothing but positive ideas to the table. Get people charged on ideas about improving their lifes. Wanting to be the best people they can be. Not supporting companies that destroy people, cigratte companies for example. And this isn't a good thing?

xsecx
11-29-2007, 02:49 PM
To say anti-flag is not considered a straight edge band is wrong. People who want to make change, for the world and themselves and bring nothing but positive ideas to the table. Get people charged on ideas about improving their lifes. Wanting to be the best people they can be. Not supporting companies that destroy people, cigratte companies for example. And this isn't a good thing?

How is it wrong, when they aren't a straight edge band? Everything you've listed is great, but has nothing to do with straight edge?

XbriX
11-29-2007, 02:54 PM
How is it wrong, when they aren't a straight edge band? Everything you've listed is great, but has nothing to do with straight edge?


it essentially boils down to the same thing of what makes a person edge. If a band refers to themselves as an edge band, then they are.

anti-flag does refer to themselves as straight edge. If you've read or watched interviews they discuss the subject often. To be the best you can be is a straightedge idea, which is a main idea within their song writing. They are more of a politicaly based band, but they have straightedge ideas within their song wrtiting, in each of their ablums.

xsecx
11-29-2007, 03:02 PM
anti-flag does refer to themselves as straight edge. If you've read or watched interviews they discuss the subject often. To be the best you can be is a straightedge idea, which is a main idea within their song writing. They are more of a politicaly based band, but they have straightedge ideas within their song wrtiting, in each of their ablums.


everything that I've seen in interviews says that they are drug free and don't use the term straight edge. They don't play hardcore shows, they don't play with straight edge bands, They aren't a hardcore band, so I'm at a loss why you'd think they'd be straight edge, when they're not actually contributing to the straight edge community in any way shape or form.

XbriX
11-29-2007, 03:15 PM
everything that I've seen in interviews says that they are drug free and don't use the term straight edge. They don't play hardcore shows, they don't play with straight edge bands, They aren't a hardcore band, so I'm at a loss why you'd think they'd be straight edge, when they're not actually contributing to the straight edge community in any way shape or form.

Actually they have played with straight edge bands such as cancer bats and rise against. They have played shows with hardcore bands, they may not be a hardcore band themselves but i can't see why, if they themselves have said they are a straight edge band, for example on the death of a nation dvd interview Justin Sane says, "
We are a straight edge band in that we don't smoke or do drugs, we will not be against anyone who does...", are not a straight edge bands when in their song writing they speak of straight edge ideas. They are not a hardcore band, they are a punk band who is straight edge. If you have listened to their music in depth you would see that they support the lifestyle. To me i see them as nothing but straight edge. I can see how you would disagree if you don't know their music well, on the outside they might seem everything but straight egde but when indeed they are

XbriX
11-29-2007, 03:22 PM
Pat Thetic - Anti-Flag Pop Culture Interview

"MG: A lot of "left wing" people kind of whine, you guys make things happen for yourselves. You're all pretty straight edge...

Pat (Drummer): Yes! We find that that's a better way for us to live and get through our lives.

MG: Although not users, based on what I'm reading, you're against criminalization of drugs?

P: We're against drug laws that criminalize addiction for sure. I think that addiction is a medical condition, the real problem with drug use are in the laws and the criminalization of the use. "

source: http://www.popculturemadness.com/interview/AntiFlag.html

xsecx
11-29-2007, 03:25 PM
Actually they have played with straight edge bands such as cancer bats and rise against. They have played shows with hardcore bands, they may not be a hardcore band themselves but i can't see why, if they themselves have said they are a straight edge band, for example on the death of a nation dvd interview Justin Sane says, "
We are a straight edge band in that we don't smoke or do drugs, we will not be against anyone who does...", are not a straight edge bands when in their song writing they speak of straight edge ideas. They are not a hardcore band, they are a punk band who is straight edge. If you have listened to their music in depth you would see that they support the lifestyle. To me i see them as nothing but straight edge. I can see how you would disagree if you don't know their music well, on the outside they might seem everything but straight egde but when indeed they are

I think you and most of the people here have very very different ideas about what straight edge is, because no one here would consider rise against, a straight edge band either. They aren't in any way contributing to the modern straight edge culture. This is what seems to be the crux of the issue, straight edge is about a lot more than just what someone doesn't do. There's a whole lifestyle and subculture that exists that bands like Rise Against and Anti-Flag have absolutely nothing to do with. Again, the lifestyle is more than just not doing drugs or smoking.

xsecx
11-29-2007, 03:27 PM
Pat Thetic - Anti-Flag Pop Culture Interview

"MG: A lot of "left wing" people kind of whine, you guys make things happen for yourselves. You're all pretty straight edge...

Pat (Drummer): Yes! We find that that's a better way for us to live and get through our lives.

MG: Although not users, based on what I'm reading, you're against criminalization of drugs?

P: We're against drug laws that criminalize addiction for sure. I think that addiction is a medical condition, the real problem with drug use are in the laws and the criminalization of the use. "

source: http://www.popculturemadness.com/interview/AntiFlag.html

and this just illustrates the point, they're misusing the term straight edge, to mean simply being against drug use, when it's more than that.

XbriX
11-29-2007, 03:37 PM
I think you and most of the people here have very very different ideas about what straight edge is, because no one here would consider rise against, a straight edge band either. They aren't in any way contributing to the modern straight edge culture. This is what seems to be the crux of the issue, straight edge is about a lot more than just what someone doesn't do. There's a whole lifestyle and subculture that exists that bands like Rise Against and Anti-Flag have absolutely nothing to do with. Again, the lifestyle is more than just not doing drugs or smoking.

Rise Against, again, i disagree is a straight edge band. Tim McIlrath speaks of it often in interviews, absoultly none you have seen or read. It is really difficult for me to grasp why they are not a straight edge band, you said yourself if a band says they are, like a person, they are. If a band speaks of straight edge ideas, says they are straight edge. I have been to straight edge hardcore shows and know about the subculture. I think that people lose sight of bands who play bigger shows, sometimes stadiums because its not so closely involved as some bands are. It may easier to say bands are more involved in the scene when they are right there all the time. If a person or a band believes in straight edge, has it in their song writing, gives people hope, are positive what is wrong with that. how are they not straight edge. Explain how they are not contruibuting to the culture. how are they not? if they speak of their beliefs, maybe let younger generations learn about straight edge, thats not being involved? Or they have to be a hardcore band that only plays shows with other hardcore straight edge bands, with x's on their hands, i've been to those shows and people forget we are human beings that believe in something good. Who is anyone to judge anyone making a great life desicion. Why, if they say their are straight edge,it so wrong? Explain to me

xsecx
11-29-2007, 04:20 PM
Rise Against, again, i disagree is a straight edge band. Tim McIlrath speaks of it often in interviews, absoultly none you have seen or read. It is really difficult for me to grasp why they are not a straight edge band, you said yourself if a band says they are, like a person, they are. If a band speaks of straight edge ideas, says they are straight edge. I have been to straight edge hardcore shows and know about the subculture. I think that people lose sight of bands who play bigger shows, sometimes stadiums because its not so closely involved as some bands are. It may easier to say bands are more involved in the scene when they are right there all the time. If a person or a band believes in straight edge, has it in their song writing, gives people hope, are positive what is wrong with that. how are they not straight edge. Explain how they are not contruibuting to the culture. how are they not? if they speak of their beliefs, maybe let younger generations learn about straight edge, thats not being involved? Or they have to be a hardcore band that only plays shows with other hardcore straight edge bands, with x's on their hands, i've been to those shows and people forget we are human beings that believe in something good. Who is anyone to judge anyone making a great life desicion. Why, if they say their are straight edge,it so wrong? Explain to me

http://www.pastepunk.com/features.php?v=118

some of the members are edge, they aren't an edge band. some of the members of afi are edge, they aren't an edge band. One of the dudes in fall out boy is edge, so would you say they are contributing to the edge culture as well?

The bands you've listed have no connection to the straight edge scene at all, so why would you say that they do? How can a band, that isn't hardcore. doesn't play hardcore shows, and isn't involved with the hardcore scene at all show younger kids about something they themselves are as a band, not a part of? Do you have any idea how much shit was caused by Davey Havok having a kid X'ing up in an afi video, because a bunch of kids thought it had something to do with AFI?

xJoelx
01-26-2008, 12:52 AM
Someone should get a list of every band thats been said so far.

Here are some more straight edge bands:
xRepresentx
xDisciplex AD
xRetaliatory Strikex
CDC
Search Bloc
Taste the Steel
Blood Of The Martyr
Stand Firm
xTyrantx
xKill Everyonex
Fear Tradition
xTo This Dayx
Rhinoceros
Domestic War
Unit 731
The Teen Idles
Hoods
Chain of Strength
XfilesX
Project X
Casey Jones
Just Say Go
Crippled Youth
Stop & Think
Sacred Pledge
XReign of TerrorX

Speaking of xReign of Terrorx, has anyone heard them/heard of them? If so, what do you think about them(or he) I don't know how many members or if there is just one, so ill just say xROTx. xROTx is straight edge rap. I think xROTx is good, i like their songs a lot but what do you guys think about them not being hardcore. If you havn't heard xROTx listen to them, i would love to know what you think. Here is there myspace myspace.com/xreignofterrorx
I think the song "Torch the Grey Area" is incredible. The lyrics are fantastic. If your going to listen to xROTx or have listened to xROTx and havn't heard that song definitely listen to it.

D1988
01-26-2008, 09:47 AM
I think Reign Of Terror is horrible. I think it's just the one guy but I really don't know to be honest. Seventh Dagger overall gets a thumbs down from me.

xcriterionmasterx
02-21-2008, 07:51 AM
i was wondering if you guys can help me compile a list of every band that has been edge past or present?

here is my list: http://rateyourmusic.com/list/criterionmaster/straight_edge_bands_musical_artists__past_and_pres ent_

it isn't in any order. but just search the site and tell me what bands i have forgot. i may also have formed in/disbanded in what year questions at some point, too.
please help. also, if someone would compile all that have already been said, that would be a great help. any band that i don't have years they formed or disbanded you can also tell me those, too. i am still working on it, but all help is appreciated.

SgtD
02-21-2008, 09:29 AM
please help. also, if someone would compile all that have already been said, that would be a great help. any band that i don't have years they formed or disbanded you can also tell me those, too. i am still working on it, but all help is appreciated.
cfa, anti-flag, strife, refused,good riddance were not edge bands. I'd also like to know why Sage Francis is on the list.

xcriterionmasterx
02-21-2008, 10:55 AM
cfa, anti-flag, strife, refused,good riddance were not edge bands. I'd also like to know why Sage Francis is on the list.
"Refused was a hardcore band originating from Umeå, Sweden. They formed in early 1991 with Dennis Lyxzén, David Sandström, Pär Hansson and Jonas Lidgren and released their first demo, Refused, the same year. The band went on to release one more demo, five EPs and three albums (not including The Demo Compilation or The EP Compilation) before breaking up in 1998. Refused's final line-up consisted of the members Dennis Lyxzén, David Sandström, Kristofer Steen and Jon Brännström who released everything from Songs to Fan the Flames of Discontent (1996) to the definitive album The Shape of Punk to Come. In this album, Refused drew heavily on the influence of the Washington, D.C. hardcore band, Nation of Ulysses, New York hardcore band Born Against, as well as the writings of Karl Marx, anarchist Errico Malatesta, and the Situationist International. The band were already well known for their vegan and straight edge stances."

"Strife released their second album, In This Defiance in 1997. This album was also well regarded by the straight edge/hardcore community. It was also notable for the guest appearances, with Chino Moreno of Deftones, Dino Cazares of Fear Factory and Igor Cavalera of Sepultura all taking turns on the album.

Two years later, Strife broke up, citing creative differences and exhaustion. Victory Records released Truth Through Defiance, a compilation of live tracks and previously unreleased material.

In 2000, Strife reunited to play several benefit concerts, and by the following year had officially reformed and released Angermeans. No longer straight edge, this album was considered by the band to be a more mature and focused continuation of In This Defiance. The band received some criticism from former fans for no longer being straight edge."

GR - was a vegan band, i don't know if they were straight edge.

sage is straight edge, he talks about it in some songs (according to a friend). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sage_Francis

"As the early ‘Edge’ bands such as Minor Threat, 7 Seconds, SSD, and Cause for Alarm began to tour the nation, their beliefs and values began to catch on. " http://www.thecornernews.com/index.php/news/comments/walking-the-straight-edge/

anti-flag is all straight edge, but don't promote it, at least to my knowledge, so i will take them off, or note that.

xGriffox
02-21-2008, 04:27 PM
not sure if they are on the list but i'm gonna put em up anyway:

The Swarm
XfilesX
Purification
Prayer For Cleansing
Arkangel
Seven Generations
Gather
Chokehold

SgtD
02-22-2008, 01:48 AM
"Refused was a hardcore band originating from Umeå, Sweden. They formed in early 1991 with Dennis Lyxzén, David Sandström, Pär Hansson and Jonas Lidgren and released their first demo, Refused, the same year. The band went on to release one more demo, five EPs and three albums (not including The Demo Compilation or The EP Compilation) before breaking up in 1998. Refused's final line-up consisted of the members Dennis Lyxzén, David Sandström, Kristofer Steen and Jon Brännström who released everything from Songs to Fan the Flames of Discontent (1996) to the definitive album The Shape of Punk to Come. In this album, Refused drew heavily on the influence of the Washington, D.C. hardcore band, Nation of Ulysses, New York hardcore band Born Against, as well as the writings of Karl Marx, anarchist Errico Malatesta, and the Situationist International. The band were already well known for their vegan and straight edge stances."

"Strife released their second album, In This Defiance in 1997. This album was also well regarded by the straight edge/hardcore community. It was also notable for the guest appearances, with Chino Moreno of Deftones, Dino Cazares of Fear Factory and Igor Cavalera of Sepultura all taking turns on the album.

Two years later, Strife broke up, citing creative differences and exhaustion. Victory Records released Truth Through Defiance, a compilation of live tracks and previously unreleased material.

In 2000, Strife reunited to play several benefit concerts, and by the following year had officially reformed and released Angermeans. No longer straight edge, this album was considered by the band to be a more mature and focused continuation of In This Defiance. The band received some criticism from former fans for no longer being straight edge."

GR - was a vegan band, i don't know if they were straight edge.

sage is straight edge, he talks about it in some songs (according to a friend). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sage_Francis

"As the early ‘Edge’ bands such as Minor Threat, 7 Seconds, SSD, and Cause for Alarm began to tour the nation, their beliefs and values began to catch on. " http://www.thecornernews.com/index.php/news/comments/walking-the-straight-edge/

anti-flag is all straight edge, but don't promote it, at least to my knowledge, so i will take them off, or note that.
ok. being vegan but not edge doesn't make them an edge band. Russ is edge though, but that's it.
The whole "straight edge rap" is bullshit. Straight edge is hardcore.
CFA was not edge anyway.
Yeah, therefore Anti flag is not a straight edge band.

what are you trying to achieve with this list by the way? It can never be complete you know...

xcriterionmasterx
02-22-2008, 07:43 AM
ok. being vegan but not edge doesn't make them an edge band. Russ is edge though, but that's it.
The whole "straight edge rap" is bullshit. Straight edge is hardcore.
CFA was not edge anyway.
Yeah, therefore Anti flag is not a straight edge band.

what are you trying to achieve with this list by the way? It can never be complete you know...
straight edge can be rap, since my feeling is most rap ripped off hardcore anyways. the lyrical content, "having a message", etc. and if they rap about straight edge things and are straight edge, then i count them. their talent wasn't hardcore, it was rapping, that doesn't mean they weren't heavily influenced by hardcore, it just means they wanted to rap about straight edge rather than scream about it. and xreign of terrorx raps during hardcore songs, too. and is the guitarist of some hardcore bands. so obviously he is involved with hardcore.

well, the site has many lists, and many of them i have used over the years. they are basically like for information and whatnot. and i noticed there were many many punk/hardcore lists, but no one had ever made a straight edge list. so i decided to. i know it is never going to be "complete", because that is fucking impossible, with all the local bands from different areas and whatnot. but it is a fun thing for me to try and do, and hopefully people will look at it, and be able to see the progression of straight edge, too. with teen idles/minor threat, to youth crew, hardline, metalcore straight edge, youth crew revival, some sxe rap, even some straight edge grindcore. :]

and i will take anti-flag and cfa off, thanks. and the vegan bands.

SgtD
02-25-2008, 08:34 AM
straight edge can be rap, since my feeling is most rap ripped off hardcore anyways. the lyrical content, "having a message", etc. and if they rap about straight edge things and are straight edge, then i count them. their talent wasn't hardcore, it was rapping, that doesn't mean they weren't heavily influenced by hardcore, it just means they wanted to rap about straight edge rather than scream about it. and xreign of terrorx raps during hardcore songs, too. and is the guitarist of some hardcore bands. so obviously he is involved with hardcore.

well, the site has many lists, and many of them i have used over the years. they are basically like for information and whatnot. and i noticed there were many many punk/hardcore lists, but no one had ever made a straight edge list. so i decided to. i know it is never going to be "complete", because that is fucking impossible, with all the local bands from different areas and whatnot. but it is a fun thing for me to try and do, and hopefully people will look at it, and be able to see the progression of straight edge, too. with teen idles/minor threat, to youth crew, hardline, metalcore straight edge, youth crew revival, some sxe rap, even some straight edge grindcore. :]

and i will take anti-flag and cfa off, thanks. and the vegan bands.
this whole straight edge rap seems bullshit to me, can't help it.

EwGrossChris
09-29-2008, 05:00 PM
The acacia strain and stick to your guns?

im asking.

SgtD
09-30-2008, 01:44 AM
The acacia strain and stick to your guns?

im asking.

what are you asking?

swallow
09-30-2008, 03:02 AM
To earlier posts on the thread..

I believe that everyone creates their own straight edge by following few basic rules; not using, not smoking, not drinking and going to gigs if possible. I'd say after that it's all up to you; what you listen, how do you look like, what you do, what you believe in.

This might be against the scene in some places (like USA, for example, where there is more edgers around) but - as example - in Finland, where THERE IS NO scene almost AT ALL (I think we had one sxe band some time ago) it's hard to "go only to sxe gigs" and "listen only to sxe".

I listen to music which sounds good. I do what I want to do, and being edge is one of those things. Edge for myself, being true to my own values and point of views. Not to judge anybody else.

xsecx
09-30-2008, 09:14 AM
To earlier posts on the thread..

I believe that everyone creates their own straight edge by following few basic rules; not using, not smoking, not drinking and going to gigs if possible. I'd say after that it's all up to you; what you listen, how do you look like, what you do, what you believe in.

This might be against the scene in some places (like USA, for example, where there is more edgers around) but - as example - in Finland, where THERE IS NO scene almost AT ALL (I think we had one sxe band some time ago) it's hard to "go only to sxe gigs" and "listen only to sxe".

I listen to music which sounds good. I do what I want to do, and being edge is one of those things. Edge for myself, being true to my own values and point of views. Not to judge anybody else.

I don't think you'd find anyone seriously advocating only listening to straight edge bands and only going to straight edge shows. I don't think it's even possible without severely limiting yourself.

Sunlightseven20
12-10-2008, 01:30 AM
it essentially boils down to the same thing of what makes a person edge. If a band refers to themselves as an edge band, then they are.

I dunno. I used to think of myself as a straightedger, but my reasons were all wrong and I was generally ignorant. Looking back I'd say I never really got it and once I did get it I decided it wasn't for me.

I don't know if that paralells with entire bands (or people who are no longer teenagers) but it'd be interesting to think about considering some of these questionable "are they edge?" bands.

kid_ugly
07-22-2009, 10:05 PM
this whole straight edge rap seems bullshit to me, can't help it.

not a rap fan?

has anyone heard of this guy Omega Impure (formally XDaXBlueXCornerX)? kinda cool semi-decent rap imo. and free music so thats always a plus, check him out.

http://www.myspace.com/dbcxxx

lo0m
07-23-2009, 01:19 AM
interesting but the download links seems to be broken, can you upload it somewhere or just point me in a right direction?

xsecx
07-23-2009, 08:17 AM
interesting but the download links seems to be broken, can you upload it somewhere or just point me in a right direction?

who are you directing this to?

SgtD
07-23-2009, 10:41 AM
not a rap fan?

has anyone heard of this guy Omega Impure (formally XDaXBlueXCornerX)? kinda cool semi-decent rap imo. and free music so thats always a plus, check him out.

http://www.myspace.com/dbcxxx

i like a lot of rap. straight edge is a movement in hardcore, not rap, it has no history in rap, and feels totally out of place. sxe belongs to hardcore